Kerbside pickup
Yes
Lucky Day Whiskey Bar in Buffalo
Categories
Location on the map
Buffalo, Erie County, New York, US
Service options
Takeaway
Yes
Dine-in
Yes
Health and safety
Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits
Yes
Highlights
Great beer selection
Yes
Great cocktails
Yes
Great wine list
Yes
Live music
Yes
Popular for
Dinner
Yes
Solo dining
Yes
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Yes
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Yes
Offerings
Alcohol
Yes
Beer
Yes
Cocktails
Yes
Coffee
Yes
Comfort food
Yes
Happy-hour drinks
Yes
Happy-hour food
Yes
Late-night food
Yes
Small plates
Yes
Spirits
Yes
Wine
Yes
Dining options
Dinner
Yes
Dessert
Yes
Seating
Yes
Amenities
Bar on site
Yes
High chairs
Yes
Toilets
Yes
Wi-Fi
Yes
Atmosphere
Casual
Yes
Cosy
Yes
Historic
Yes
Upmarket
Yes
Crowd
Family friendly
Yes
Groups
Yes
LGBTQ+ friendly
Yes
Tourists
Yes
Transgender safe space
Yes
Planning
Accepts reservations
Yes
Payments
Debit cards
Yes
Credit cards
Yes
Phone: +1 716-322-0547
Site: http://www.luckydaywhiskeybar.com/
Site: http://www.luckydaywhiskeybar.com/
Opening hours
- Monday:Closed
- Tuesday:4PM–12AM
- Wednesday:4PM–12AM
- Thursday:4PM–12AM
- Friday:4PM–1AM
- Saturday:4PM–1AM
- Sunday:Closed
Comments (199)
Moody vibes. Like youve snuck into your grandfathers whiskey club in 1920s elite society. Doesnt hurt that the drinks are expertly crafted and served in gorgeous thick, star emblem glasses. The scallops were light and buttery and the grilled Cesar was the perfect mix of charred and tangy. Service exceeded expectations. Tuck yourself in a corner and soak up the ambiance!!
Very very nice dinner. Got the fillet with mash potatoes and it was super tasty and perfectly cooked! Atmosphere is magic but i think we got there in the wrong night, a party was on and too many drunk ppl yelling and shouting 😂 😂 but I will definitely go back as dinner was amazingly tasty
Enjoyed dinner tonight. We had the vegetarian cheese steak, shrimp cocktail, and broccolini My husband also liked his Old Fashioned, and the chocolate mousse was good, but on the small side. The only thing that wasnt as good was the Brussels sprouts because they were not cooked enough, and were too hard to enjoy.
These guys really know how to mix drinks properly! And the happy hour food prices are insanely cheap. Had a burger worth $25 for $6 :)Will definitely be back soon!
We tried this restaurant because of its convenient location to our hotel and we were not disappointed. We werent able to make a reservation, but sitting at the bar was worth the experience. The bar tender was super talented and that was just the beginning. My husband had their smash burger special and I had the roasted chicken. Both meals were phenomenal. The chicken was cooked so perfectly I could barely stop from drooling after every bite. Glad we stumbled into this place!
Quite possibly the best Brussel sprouts we’ve had. The bartender can make any drink and it’s obvious he’s very experienced. I love the atmosphere. I would definitely recommend.
I went here for a dinner and the service was phenomenal. I enjoyed the Bourbon Chicken and my server Jake was absolutely fantastilc. 10/10. I highly recommend giving this place a try.
The best part of this place is the dollar oysters at the bar from 3-6 everyday. That’s right- not just Mon-Fri but Sat and Sun, too! The bar is incredibly stoked from floor to ceiling, and I adore the wooden ladder on wheels, that glides across it for easy access to the top shelves. The bar staff is dressed in adorable vests, and while that shouldn’t be a draw in an of itself, it is. The decor is dark and moody- perfect for a wintertime meal or a few smooth drinks. I place a lot of stock in the decor, and was thrilled that they had leather couches in the front bar section to sit in, and nice touches like a large bison head, bold printed wallpapers, and thick wooden beams. I went recently for my birthday, and they were able to accomodate a large group of 12, and were incredibly nice and thoughtful during service. We didn’t feel rushed, and they let us linger for hours at our table. They also let us bring our own cake! I had such a lovely time, I cannot recommend it enough. The vibe was great, and we got to hear a live band from the upper floor. Also, the drinks are STRONG!
Best whiskey selection around, including a fairly good japanese collection. I like the fact that they set the bottle in front of you at the bar so you can examine and read the bottle, nice touch. Got the burger and mac n cheese, pretty large portions and tasted good. Great service and good conversation with the bartenders, reasonable prices
Great Manhattan and beautiful but I only go here if invited because it is very noisy. If you like a bustling atmosphere, you will love it!!
Wow this is the perfect example of a great whiskey bar. Huge selection. Knowledgeable and competent bartenders. Exquisite design. Quality food menu. This place had a wonderful historic feel to it, and you can tell every detail had been thoroughly thought out, from the elegant and timely lighting fixtures, the dark wood, the classy seating, and even down to the brass tacks. The super old refrigerators are cool. The level of detail is impeccable. Highly, highly recommend. Best treasure in Buffalo.
Best. Whiskey Bar. Ever. I was blown away by the selection here and the bartenders are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. Their old fashioneds are out of this world and its the best place to try a new pour before buying a bottle. We were in town for a week for work and ended up back here twice. I cant wait to go back.
The salads are always great here. Ive had the caesar which is highly authentic as well as the house which is a very full mix of greens and some pickled onions on top.The roasted chicken and elk were also both really good although I think I liked the chicken more.They have an extensive selection of beers and whiskey; the real draw to this place.Not open on Sundays or Mondays from what I remember. Worth going for the ambiance and music. Highly recommended.
Amazing atmosphere! Attentive service. Delicious food and drink! Bourbon! Fantastic music!!!
Went for restaurant week. Service was great and drinks were delicious. The hand pie was AMAZING. We also had the steak which was just okay. I will definitely come back again for hand pies
Great selection of whiskeys, especially bourbons, and friendly, knowledgeable staff. I will be returning to try the food as Ive heard the burgers are very good. I went to hear an acoustic folk/rock duo and the only problem was the awkward set up/location for the musicians.
The wife and I were looking for a place to go before a concert at Key Bank Arena. We decided to checkout places a little further from the arena but close to the subway. Lucky Day was perfect. Its a 1 minute walk to the train. We almost didnt go because of all the bad reviews on the food, but Im a whiskey fanatic, and heard their selection was incredible. Im so glad we ended up going. The food was incredible! I ordered the Rainbow Trout, and my wife ordered the Steak Burger. Her burger was perfectly medium rare and juicy. The fries were fresh cut potatoes seasoned perfectly. My fish had an awesome mushroom sauce and was perfectly flaky as a fish should be presented with again, great seasoning. The staff was very attentative. My only gripe is the bar is elevated about 3 feet, and the tables are against the drop off, so the volume of the bar chatter funnels through the lower dining section. I have a decibel meter app on my phone that was rating 82.6db. It was very difficult to carry on a conversation. Food, drinks, bartenders, staff, vibe, etc incredible!!! We cant wait to go back. Bar volume? Theres probably nothing they can do about it short of a sound buffer, but it was loud.
Great food! Had bone marrow, beef tartar and brisket sliders! Everything was fantastic. And of course a few drinks. Never been let down there 👍
Love coming here with new people. One of the best fun restaurants in Buffalo for sure! If you like bourbon, dont think, just go here.
Me and my wife Lydia come in from Ohio every year to get some Dino BBQ and golf at that one place thats also a dog park. Usually we leave the same day, but this time Lydia says to me, she says Oh Bob, why dont we take some friends with us this year and get a B&B or something and stay the night. We havent had a vacation in years! I think that sounds great, so thats what we did. We had a slot open on Saturday night to eat something other than Dino, so we decided to try Lucky Day.Boy am I glad we did! Im not very good with these computers these days, but I definitely had to write about this place, since if anyone is ever wondering if theyre real good, theyre real good! Isabel was our server and my buddy was making fun of me for getting a lemon wedge with my Bourbon, so she brings out some Splenda to go with it :) The place is packed, but they got these little nooks so you feel like its just you in there. My steak was so good I ended up getting another one for dessert, and since technically it was my birthday she ended up putting a candle in my mashed potatoes! We finished with a shot of some kind of whiskey that they play music to while its aging. Never heard of that before, didnt taste any different than regular whiskey, but well definitely remember it, thats for sure!Anyway, every minute of our time there was great, the food was great, the drinks were great, and Isabel probably gave us the best dining experience weve had in the last 5 years at least. Great job all around!
Food was good, but wasnt notified they will not serve you if you cant provide proof of vaccination when I made the reservation. Half of our group wanted to leave, including me, but we decided to stay. Wont be going back to spend money at a restaurant trying to be the vaccine police. Food was good enough to earn 2 stars despite how disappointed we were in their ignorant requirement. I recommend everyone think twice about spending money here until their lift their discriminatory mandate. Scary times when establishments require people to show their papers to enter.
A great whiskey bar with knowledgeable and accommodating bartenders. They have an extensive inventory, you can enjoy the familiar and never had libations of your choice. I was told its a local ordnance, all Buffalo bars must have a bison.
Excellent beer, a wall of whiskey. The most tragically hipster environment you could ask for including bunned, tattooed, bearded bar tenders. I mean what more could you ask for but some funky live music. Highly recommend, often standing room only.
This tavern was a pleasant surprise. Good atmosphere with better food. I had the filet mignon, well done, but like most places, it came to me medium well. It was still great, cooked to perfection. The grilled broccoli was charred perfectly, giving it a great flavor. This place had the best sprouts I’ve had in my life, no exaggeration. Get them. The lobster tail I had added to it was overpriced, and the mashed potatoes were good but not stellar. Even so, it was the best meal I’ve had in Buffalo to date.
Spend a lot of time here working in the area in Buffalo and used to love going to this very well-stocked Whiskey Bar. Unfortunately they now require a vaccine card to even get in the door. Chose to go to a restaurant underneath my hotel that didnt discriminate.
Great place to chill and have a nice drink with friends. My one complaint was that I wish they had better choices for appetizers. It was just oysters and pickles. Kind of odd drinking food.
Had my Grandpa’s 99th Birthday there! He loved it. Great whiskey selection to boot!
My very first dinner at Lucky Day! Such an amazing place!! I love the exposed brick and hardwood floors!! Check out my beautiful drink- bourbon berry lemonade! The handpies are amazing!
Great spot to end the evening. Very good whiskey & bourbon selection along with many other imbibements that might fit anyones appetite. Had a really good chicken po boy as well. Staff is knowledgeable, friendly and very professional. I will definitely visit again. When I do I really hope they have love music again. That really made the night.
Amazing whiskey bar right across the street from the Hyatt and around the block from the convention center. The selection of whiskeys in all price ranges is impressive. The service is friendly and helpful, but it gets a little crowded on weekends after 10.
Dined at Lucky Day with about three chefs and five other bartenders so, needless to say, our standards were already high going into this place. We were greeted at the door by a lovely young woman named Leah who was such an amazing hostess it might have added an extra star to the food with this app permitted it.Between all of us, we might have ordered every cocktail, every appetizer and every fish in the menu and it was all amazing. I particularly loved the scallops.Lucky Day does not miss a best with their suggestions on pairing because, as you might imagine, they pretty much had every whiskey you could imagine. Our waitress was amazing, the cocktails were perfectly crafted, the host was inviting and the food was to die for. As a Buffalo resident, I plan to be back to Lucky Day Whiskey Bar monthly.
Great bourbon menu and delicious food. Very cool bar area and exciting atmosphere.
Upscale dinner and drinks for classy adults!I have been here a few times for drinks and have always enjoyed myself. The whiskey, wine and cocktail selection is always superb. The ambiance is a little old world, dark, dim lighting and kind of romantic. Real furniture and heavy glassware round out an upscale adult evening.I came recently for a friends birthday dinner. I had not heard much about the food but we were in for a treat. To start we had the lucky day bacon, Shishito peppers and crab croquettes. All cooked to perfection, seasoned well and delicious. For my main I had the scallops which were cooked wonderfully with the perfect sear. The sweet corn and saffron risotto were a delicate touch to the sweetness of the scallop. My significant other had the shrimp pesto linguine. There were a few large shrimp, cooked and seasoned well. The pistachio was a nice twist on the pesto.The service was also top notch. Not over the top but attentive and always there when you needed something. We were treated to some lovely jazz music during dinner. The absolute perfect evening.
A great spot to enjoy a late night cocktail! Over 600 bottles, so lots of options! Its a dark bar with comfortable seating, and occasional live music.
Limited menu. The lucky day burger was cooked to order. Gouda Mac and cheese with bacon was tasty and cheesy. Sooo good I didnt take a photo till the end of my whiskey flight special.
We were blown away by our meal. We switched up the wedge salad and had ranch dressing on it instead which was amazing. My friend had the bourbon chicken and mashed potatoes, I had a special that was brisket and ricotta cheese ravioli. Despite being stuffed we couldn’t stop eating. The staff was friendly and attentive.
Wonderful little place. The whiskey flight was totally worth it. The happy hour drinks were tasty and a great deal. I got the lucky day bacon and it was delicious. Both bartenders were very friendly gentleman who knew a lot about the products. They do more that whiskey! My friend got a white russian, she was very pleased with it. Excellent drinks. Reasonable prices, although bear in mind its a high end whiskey bar so there are some pricey options available.
Best Whisky bar in Buffalo. They have everything, and I mean EVERYTHING you could ever want to try. Yes, they get a fair market price for a pour but they have it, and its priced competitively for the market.Their food is great too and they have some great bands. Its one of my favorite hang outs in the city for sure!
Visited before Blue Jays game during happy hour. The $6 Old Fashioneds and Manhattans are good deals, as was the happy hour fried chicken sandwich. But the best thing we had was the scallops and risotto which was excellent. Bar has a great vibe and selection of whiskey/ bourbon.
Enjoyed the Happy Hour. Great staff!
Went here for a hen night and had wonderful service and food!
How can a “whiskey bar” not know the appropriate glass for a whiskey sour? Seems pretty basic.
Super cute building and delicious drinks. One of the best old fashioned drinks Ive ever had. Not super food choices though, so more of an after-dinner spot. Also took a really long time for drinks to be made, so Id suggest ordering that first and ordering before you finish the first if youre going to have more.
This place cares about you. The staff is hardworking, professional, and consistent in their excellence. Great date spot.
Food was delicious! Was a bit dark for me to see the menu without my phone light 😆
The atmosphere and food at lucky day whiskey bar deserve 5 stars. The cocktail list is sophisticated and well rounded, but poorly executed. All of our drinks tasted extremely watered down. The whisky sour was also disappointing having the incorrect mouth feel and a translucent quality that is certainly not the standard of a place of this caliber. Maybe just the wrong mixologists were working that evening, but, left a lot to be desired in a cocktail bar.
One of the best places in Buffalo! Little on the pricey side but worth it. Food is amazing, huge whiskey selection, great whiskey cocktails (but they also have a full bar if you dont like whiskey), and the staff is very friendly and welcoming.
Has a great selection of whiskeys and cocktails. The atmosphere is nice and relaxing. My only complaint is that live music started playing and it was so loud that you couldnt have a conversation with anyone.
Always a good time there. The gentlemen behind the bar are very knowledgeable about the liquors available. Happy hour is worth a visit. They pours are good. The menu is very good. Lucky Day been a regular visit. I must stop. You wont be disappointed.
If one cant find a whiskey or bourbon here to try then youre not looking hard enough. Choices galore! Limited food menu but dishes excellently prepared. Bacon appetizer with whiskey pickles are delicious as are the burgers and the cheesecake.
Had the bourbon chicken, was very nicely prepared. Fun to look at the whiskey wall
Had the two house Old Fashions, the first rye and the other bourbon to start off. Perfect ratio and not too sweet. Great service and a fantastic meal. Lagavulin Distillers Edition 16 Year Sherry Finished to finish it all off.
Ive popped in here a couple times now. I spent some time at the bar which was very lively. The prices very wildly depending on what you order, but overall tends to be pretty expensive. The first cocktail I ordered I enjoyed. I enjoyed it so much that I ordered it a second time, but the second time it came it was prepared differently and was noticeably worse. Almost as if an ingredient had been forgotten. When Im paying so much for a single cocktail I expect it to be perfect every single time.The food is pretty good. Its basically upscale pub food.The atmosphere is definitely what would keep me coming back. It has a very cool old buffalo feel. Almost a factory turned speakeasy in the night feel.
Oh my lord!!! We had oysters, followed by the bone marrow appetizer, then the elk entree and the chicken/bacon/leek pocket thing. Insanely tasty. Eat here and die happy!
This place is very cool. Awesome trendy restaurant that obviously takes the time to offer quality food and drinks. The whiskey menu is extensive and the food prices are very fair. We sat in a private booth with curtains on a busy night. We walked in with no reservations and were seated right away. They had a blues band that was pretty good. The whole experience felt unique and authentic. Although it felt like I should have waxed my mustache before walking in the crowd and wait staff were all really cool and friendly. I have been to other places with similar menus where the crowd and staff carry a pretentious attitude. This was not the case in my experience so I gave a 5 star review. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and would love to return if Im in the area again.
Stopped in for dinner. Service was good but it was hard to hear our server because the music was pretty loud. Overall, the drinks were fantastic, chicken and waffles appetizer was amazing. Entrees (steak/lobster and bourbon glazed chicken) were good but nothing to write home about. Whiskey selection was expansive and the menu was broken down nicely by type and region.
I keep finding myself at this place, and bringing more and more friends back each time. Best Old Fashioned in the area hands down. Bartenders are all extremely knowledgeable on their whiskeys. Definitely try the hand pies. The portions are huge! Good live music on Wednesday nights and the weekend oyster specials are not to be missed!
It was a good bar, but definitely not a cocktail experience, as pretentious as that sounds.We waited about 20 minutes for a table on a Saturday evening and had a great time once we were seated. Our waiter was professional and spry.Small bar area compared to the dining room. Great atmosphere and aesthetic.
Thought I was going for whiskey, but the food was banging!!!!!!! Amazing riveted. Best onion rings ever. Short rib pie was phenomenal.
Always a delicious meal here--even the Brussels sprouts are amazing. Staff is always friendly, atmosphere is swanky and relaxed. And the most incredible bourbon selection Ive ever seen!
Every once in a while, one encounters a restaurant that does such a good job, they deserve a second positive review. The Lucky Day is one such place. Its a very attractive barroom that one feels immediately comfortable in. The whisky selection is amazingly broad and deep. During happy hour 6.00 will buy you an old fashioned or a Manhattan, plus there are freshly shucked oysters for a dollar a piece. A very solid menu rounds out the food side. Service at the bar was 5 star. I would not pass through Buffalo and miss an opportunity to visit the Lucky Day. Well done for sure.
Neat bar/restaurant. Steak with coffee rub was decent and unique. Lobster and Gouda Mac and cheese were excellent. Brownie with peanut butter ice cream was great. Chicken and waffle appetizer was good. Service was decent. Good whiskey and bourbon selection.
Super cool Whiskey Bar with an Irish/German style menu and decor. I ordered hand pies and a pickle plate and would highly recommend both. Reasonably priced and menu online and can even make reservations on there too for convenience if youre like me and want to look before you show up!
One of the best whiskey selections in Buffalo, and their mixed drinks are top notch. Love the paintings and wallpapers used through the place. Intimate dining atmosphere and overall great bar. Staff is always friendly and willing to give a suggestion when looking to try something new.
Me and my wife Lydia come in from Ohio every year to get some Dino BBQ and golf at that one place thats also a dog park. Usually we leave the same day, but this time Lydia says to me, she says Oh Bob, why dont we take some friends with …
The young lady at the front desk of the Hyatt hotel across the street recommended this for a cocktail .... its a 15 second walk away. This place has a phenomenal whiskey selection and a terrific cocktail menu. I went with a Sazerac and was perfectly satisfied!! Certainly not the cheapest cocktail around but wonderful bar tenders along with the selection make this a great cocktail choice.
An absolutely amazing place to end up or even start and stay with. The late night menu is absolutely delicious, their fries are crispy, and the vegan mac and cheese is to die for. The pickle plate is both interesting and delicious! The wait staff checked in with us, and the atmosphere is so comfortable. I will absolutely come here again, and with friends too!
Love this bar. If they have the squash blossoms on the menu get them, they are fantastic! I much prefer sitting at the bar than at a table though, it tends to get really warm down in the restaurant area. But the food and drinks are always great, and the live music is always nice.
I love it here. It sort of blends in but stands out at the same time. The Camerons kick will definitely give you a kick in the kiester. I got the crab croquettes and they were fantastic. the pickled daikon was perfect and the aoili was phenomenal.
Excellent food, great atmosphere. We had the salmon which came with greens, a version of carmelized onions and two delicious sauces one a scallop cream. We also loved the sirloin tips and fries, there was an excellent sauce with this dish also. The coffee was really good, a little smoky and their eclair was split open and covered with fresh fruit.... Almost a healthy dessert. A really excellent meal. We plan to go back some time when we can try what looked like 300 choices of whiskey.
Best cocktails in Western New York. More whiskey selections than you can even dream. Plus, the staff is filled with knowledge and super friendly. Just go, you wont be disappointed. Its in the heart of downtown and walking distance from multiple hotels, always a good thing.
Of course a great selection of whiskey and other spirits. Hard to choose but the bartenders can make recommendations. Food was good and large portions if youre hungry! Menu shows gluten free options if you need them (though theres only a couple and I didnt see any main entrees).
Was my first time at Lucky day and enjoyed it . Probably the largest selection of whiskey in the area. The bar is slightly upscale in dress, and makes for a fun atmosphere. The bartenders were great and attentive. Will be back again soon
Great people! Great cocktails! Great food! Best oysters!
This place was great! We had a large party and had reservations. We did family style and loved everything we had! The duck wings appetizer was delicious, but super spicy!! The squash and brussel sprouts were amazing!! We had red wine, so I cant say much about the whiskey drinks.
Come for the whiskey--stay for the food, and the atmosphere, and the live music, and the warmth. The shepherds pie and the bone-in pork chop are two of the best dishes Ive had in Buffalo. Highly suggest this location for anyone looking to impress their visiting friends/family.
What a great find. The number of whiskey and bourbons are staggering. The bartenders were very friendly and knowledgeable. Definitely will return.
An amazing whisky selection and a phenomenal Atmosphere. My only complaint was that it felt a bit understaffed to handle the Friday evening rush. Otherwise the food was phenomenal and the wiskey was supurb. I wish they had eye droppers to help dilute the whiskey otherwise great atmosphere, great bar, be sure to catch happy hour.
It was ok. Food is good. The band on Saturday night have been there every Saturday and they act it. The looked bored which made us bored...
Only stopped in for one drink, I cant wait to return. One of the coolest old buildings downtown, so many unique features. I had and old fashioned, bartenders choice on the bourbon used, and it was good. Dont know what it cost me, but Ill have another. Hopefully soon.
Expansive whiskey menu (duh) and fantastic bartending staff. Cool atmosphere and live music. I had a Sazerac which was delicious. Highly recommend checking this place put at least once even if youre not a whiskey fan and let them staff suggest something new for you to try.
Amazing selection of whiskey and scotch. Was pleasantly surprised when I came in this place. Bartenders were nice, well informed, and more then happy to help me pick a whiskey. Food was also great. Would highly recommend a visit for anyone who likes whiskey or scotch.
Fantastic food, drinks ambience and service!!
In downtown Buffalo, the place is right across the old Genesee Building, which is now the Hyatt Hotel. They have an amazing assortment of whiskeys and bourbons. The day I went there they had a live jazz band. The atmosphere is inviting and warm. They have other liquor there as well, but why else would you go to a whiskey bar?
Establishment requires proof of a fake vaccination. This place does not deserve my money
A popular bar in the City of Buffalo. It doesnt look like much from the outside but the inside is very inviting with a warm and friendly atmosphere. With a huge bar area. The drinks and food are delicious. I was drinking Manhattans with Sweet Vermouth. I would reccomend making a reservation if you plan on eating dinner there, you dont need one, but it does fill up fast. I would definitely go back again.
Loved this place. has a cool hipster vibe with live music, at least they did the Thursday night I was there.
Whiskeys youve never heard of? Check. A warm atmosphere? Check. Loud but not so loud you cant hear the person next to you talking music? Check. Oysters sourced from nova Scotia? I dunno about always but the night I went....check. Everythings on the pricey side but thats about par for downtown buffalo and the plus to it all is the burger knows what its doing and its doing it well (not too big, and the chef picks the toppings, which in my particular case made for a fun experience; the chef nailed it with a slice of thick bacon and mushrooms). I will definitely be going back and while the color palette is your typical hipster/yuppie brown, and I mean brown...the bar the lights the walls etc...warm but ubiquitous broooown, the ambiance and sophisticated flavors more than make up for it. Easily recommend it.
Hands down one of if not the best whiskey bars on the east coast, and certainly the best in Buffalo. Super knowledgeable staff that are super accommodating, great food to complement delicious drinks, and a whiskey selection that will make your head spin. Hands on ownership that is usually there making sure your time is amazing, this is the kind of place youll tell your grandkids you had the pleasure of enjoying. A true whiskey drinkers destination if you live in NY or the surrounding areas of Buffalo.
Amazing cocktails and spirit selection! Food menu is small and a bit limited, but steak fries and scallop dinner were cooked nicely! Would highly recommended for drinks or a night cap.
Great selection of whiskey/scotch but CHASE the bartender has no clue about anything scotch. I consider myself a food and fine drink specialist at its worst. I asked this gentleman quite a fee questions and he couldnt answer one of them without running to his screen of knowledge. Told him smokey wasnt a option and yet smokey is all he could offer. Dont blow smoke hood sir when you know little. Your service has gone smokey.EDIT: A friend I was with ended up saying something to Frank, the other tender. He completely saved the day.. well educated! Returned with a sample of perfections. Revised original review fro. m 1 to 3 stars from original. Will return to edit/add.
My girlfriend and I just went for a little while and we happened to hit their happy hour which they apparently run everyday from 4 - 6 and you can get either $6 Manhattans or old fashioneds along with either $6 fried chicken sandwiches or burgers, all of which were great!
Food was delicious. Tried the burgers, fresh oysters, sausage & steak. The whiskey selection is ridiculous. Had Japanese whiskey for the first time. A scotch flight and Jefferson Ocean. It was a wonderful experience looking forward to going back.
Once inside, the place is very dim, but small alcoves of booths and tables are more brightly lit. Walls are exposed brick and beautiful woodwork separates each area of the place into a nice bar space, and more intimate seating. A large Buffalo head watches over the place from the front, and knowledgeable bartenders will whip up any drink on the menu, or even their own creation with bourbon or whiskey.
Best Whiskey bar in 10 towns, hands downs. Huge selection, fair prices, top shelf ambience, and high grade materials/workmanship throughout for an all-around VERY pleasant experience.
My fave place in Bflo to grab some whiskey. Bartenders and waitresses are always friendly, and sometimes have live music.
First time there. The bartenders were quite knowledgeable about the Scotch from Scotland and the Bourbons. Their recommendation based on our palate was perfect. Great ambiance, will definitely go back.
Fantastic place to have a drink. Great variety of whiskey. Best whiskey bar in Buffalo.
Each time I visit, more whiskies have been added. Great selection of every variety from around the world, with reasonable prices to check out basically anything. Only bar in Buffalo that I can respect as a whiskey establishment.
Liberty Hound was my 2019 Restaurant Week pick of the week. It is tradition for me to always make sure I get to at least one restaurant though I happily visit more if I am able. I had a decent level of expectation knowing how popular this place is, especially with it being right in the heart of Canalside. It is always overflowing with happy commotion on summer nights with patio dining on the water and live music sometimes either hosted here or nearby.
Didnt expect Buffalo to be so cool. Lots of bars downtown and it was packed on a Saturday night. This is just across from the Hyatt Regency and was our last stop... for over two hours! Fantastic old bar back with a ladder and 500 plus bottles of rare liquor. And great bartenders who can suggest what to try. Lots of class from the good old days.
Great low-light atmosphere, giant whiskey selection, and no problems with the service. Menu was a bit limited for my unsophisticated pallette, but the hand pies were a delicious option! Would definitely go back for a light meal and conversation-type evening.
Superb selection and knowledge of fine bourbon and whiskey. Dinner was phenomenal with our party being impressed with the steak and chicken entrees followed by exquisite desserts.
Great atmosphere - huge selection of whiskey 🥃
Lucky day is a very comfortable upscale place. Not unlike Buffalo proper, or like Vera back in its hayday. But somehow its a little more comfortable. Even with being packed in like sardines on a Saturday night and having a long wait for drinks, the atmosphere and live music made up for it. And the drinks of course. Such care put into them and a very extensive selection. Whiskey lovers can really get lost in what they have.
Very nice atmosphere. The waitresses r pretty knowledgeable of the selection of whiskys wich was pretty impressive. If u r a Whiskey connoisseur, I would definitely recommend this place. Had a very enjoyable time n loved the band.
Incredible whiskey selection, nice atmosphere, and good food. I went here on Wednesday while I was in town for work and sat at the bar. Good service, knowledgeable bartender, and a simple unpretentious menu.
Awesome selection of Whiskey and food that compliments it. Love the low key attitude and live music.
Have a shellfish allergy be and while making me drink the bartender decided to stop and clean up oysters from another person (super unprofessional). The bartender then comes back to making our drinks and doesnt wash his hands! I politely told him about this and he gave serious attitude and then decided to make jokes about it! Ive been to this bar many other times and have had great experiences but wont be back again. This bartender was as unprofessional as they come!
Serving any kind of whiskey you could ever ask for, Lucky Day also provided great service and had old school booths with privacy curtains for a more private experience if wanted. All drinks were made to perfection and the atmosphere is just what you want for a more sophisticated night out. I highly recommend!
A very nice place, old school ambiance, aesthetically pleasing a very long bar with great drinks. Service was fantastic and food was delicious. Recommend the booths for dinning, its like your own little dinning room. Definitely going again.
If all you care about is whiskey selection this is the place for it. A bit overcrowded. With all the drunk bartenders hanging half off of ladders with no fall support this place is begging for an OSHA visit. The menu is extensive and there wasnt a whiskey I wanted that they didnt have. I wont go out of my way for this spot but Id hit it up if I were in the area.
This place makes whiskey sours the correct way with the egg white, which not all bars do. Also whoever they got for the live music was great, instead of just covering popular songs they put their own unique twist on it.
This bar was awesome! Great drinks....the food was delicious 😋 Will be back...
Gorgeous bar, staff are very friendly and knowledgeable - thanks for the drink suggestion!! Service was prompt. We shared a few appetizers which were all delicious. We will absolutely be back again!!
Loved this fun and unique bar!! The bartenders know their stuff and dont try to push pricier bourbons... they really want you to have a fabulous experience! We went back every night we were in town!
Awesome. Great food and drink.
Very disappointed with the staff here. I originally gave this place an outstanding review, but it has definitely changed. I was out for my birthday and my party of 17 stopped here for some drinks.I ordered a round to say thanks to my party and the bar made a drink that was not so great. My guest wanted to return their drink in exchange for a glass of wine. I asked for a glass of Chardonnay. The bartender did not disclose how much this glass of wine was.There is a glass of Chardonnay on the menu for $8, which I was expecting. The bartender poured a glass of their $28 a glass version without warning. I got the bill and disputed the charge regarding this. The bartender apologized, but did not correct his mistake. He still charged me for both drinks.Im upset with this staff because they did not fix their mistake and they should warn their customers that instead of the $8 dollar glass, the $28 glass is what they are pouring. I would have totally changed my selection before the pour.I hope they improve their customer relations soon because I did like coming to their location. I often show up there with parties of 15 or larger. Poor customer service.
Lively whisky bar with amazing selection and awesome music playlist at a perfect volume to still be able to have a chat. Food is cooked well, but much was underseasoned and kind of boring. Would come back for drinks!*Update: In the past couple months (March, April 2018) several friends have said that I need to go again, as the food is very good now. I went and was amazed at the improvement compared to last year when we went. There are many places to get great food in Buffalo, and LD has gone from something I wouldnt have bothered coming back to eat to a restaurant that I will prioritize coming to, now.
The best back bar I have ever seen. The bar staff were both knowledgeable and friendly and made great suggestions for myself and my friend based on what we currently drank. I will be back and I recommend any whiskey drinker do the same.
Stopped in to this establishment for a cocktail Fri night around 10 pm 01/03/2020. Bar area was very crowded restaurant area was very quite so after getting a drink from the bar I took a seat at a table to watch the band that was playing and was approached buy a rude hostess who told me i could not sit at the table when i asked why she got an attitude with me so i told her i wanted to talk to the manager. The woman mng on that night came up to me and told me and asked what the problem way i said there was no problem we were just having some drinks and watching the band she went on to tell me that we could not sit at the table they were for dinner guests only!!! I said there is 30 empty tables and 3 TABLES eating she didnt care just flat out RUDE. So if planning to visiting this place make sure you understand what area you allowed in and which you are not I would have stayed for a few more drinks if they would have just let me sit in the EMPTY dinning area but apparently that a BIG no I will not return to this place ever again
Terrific place. Beautiful location, exposed brick. Terrific display of the whiskey bottles, and excellent selection. Good whiskey cocktails as well. I would love to return. Had live jazz as well.
Comfortable atmosphere and a good amount of seating. We got happy hour old fashions for $6 which was an excellent value and sat in front of the windows. They have an overwhelming amount of alcohol.
As thorough a selection of bourbon, rye, or scotch as youll find anywhere. Cocktails made with skill and very reasonably priced. Excellent service. It feels like youve stepped back in time when you walk inside.
This is a great place for after work drinks and dinner. The best whiskey selection in Buffalo. Awesome service from bar and wait staff. If that’s not enough the interior will make you want to stay and relax.
Great cocktails and great food. The pies are delicious especially the duck wings a must try. Also try the scotch eggs. My favorite is the short rib stroganoff.
Fantastic whiskey cocktails at the low-end of the price spectrum. Bartenders show care and exceptional craftsmanship in the making of this swanky establishments libations. Vibes A++
Classy whiskey bar with a vast selection! Only stopped in for drinks this time but hopefully can stop back one day.
300 Whiskeys back in July, 400 by the end of August, aiming for 600+ in October, and the bartenders know a little about every single one. Plus the food is amazing (some of it is $$, but theyve got a $5 burger thats delectable)
Decent place with knowledgeable bar staff!!! thats huge, especially for someone like me who loves a good old fashioned just dont know much about it.... my only disapotment was the smell.... maybe they need to improve circulation or get some candles, something smelled weird the whole time I was there with my boss.
Great experience here. Our server Rob was great, the management was wonderful. Food was perfect portions and great price. The selection of whiskey was incredible. We will definitely be back.
A revamp of what used to be Century Grill. Although they still kept the two tired seating structure and the general aesthetic of the rest of the place, the vibe feels classic and new at the same time. The cocktails were on point and they had an oyster special when I stopped in. Any place that makes a perfect sazarac is awesome in my books.
Cant say Ive ever eaten or drunk there, and never will, but I will say I turned down two jobs waiting to get a spot as a barback at this place and wasnt even given the time of day when I kept calling to inquire about my Hiring packet.At the end of the day, I wouldnt eat at a place where the owners are too lazy to pick up a phone and conduct themselves in a professional manner. Thanks for the job losses guys.
Awesome collection of spirits, knowledgeable bartenders, nice atmosphere. Sometimes live music, if that is your thing. And perfect location across from the Hyatt, should you be staying there.
If youre after a wide variety of whiskey, this is certainly the place to get your fill. I will leave others to describe how accurate/knowledgeable the staff is, but I can say that you can get into a large bar tab with ease! Tasty!
Love their cocktails, cant beat the whiskey/bourbon/rye selection! Will have to come back for a bite to eat someday... also, how can you not love a bar with a portait of a cat holding a dead rabbit?
Great whiskey selection. Food was decent. They do a great job separating tables
Got drinks with the lads here a couple of weeks ago to break up the USMLE step studying. Solid drinks, fancy interior and upscale environment with good service
The food was inscrutable and the service impeccable. I dont know what else to say...oh wait...lobster tail and lamb pops were perfectly prepared, as were the sides. Ill be back for sure! 😋 And very inexpensive.
Great spot with a awesome selection of whiskey. The low lighting vibe was a nice touch
Of the three days I spent in Buffalo, two of them ended at the Lucky Day. The spirit selection is outstanding and the staff is knowledge, un-pretentious and non-judgmental. This place is a must-see for the casual drinker and the connoisseur alike.
Its a little oasis of class downtown. A lovely bar to enjoy a wide variety of whiskey. I had a great time, and will come again
Couldn’t find a reason not to give it any less than 5 stars. First time here but the service food atmosphere and drink were all great, and what is a restaurant but those four things? Looking forward to coming back for round two, bringing some friends, and seeing if my first impressions ring true again
Love this bar, love the choice in bourbon. I just hope the owners read this because a suggestion to make it even better would to have descriptions of the whiskey on the menus. I got annoyed looking everything up on my cell phone.
Not just for whiskey lovers! Ambiance is welcoming and historic while maintaining a modern feel. Unique to say the least!
This place is amazing! Best Manhattan I have ever had. Great food, make sure you get a trasher burger!Good service as well, you cant go wrong here.
Creative and delicious food. Great whiskey menu! Staff is knowledgeable and helpful. Really good music too. A must!
Loved the environment and the food! The whiskey selection is superb!
Great food, perfect atmosphere. Band was fantastic. Quaint decor with a little class and a little sass. Try it. You have a great evening.
Only one option for a vegetarian.The one drink I did have, cost more than my entrée. The staff was friendly, the service was a little slow. This is a one and done
Isobel was wonderful at seating us in a quiet place so we could enjoy the atmosphere while we sipped a lovely drink
Great bardenters and huge selection of whiskey. Not to be missed
The largest collection of whiskey, bourbon, and scotch Ive ever seen in one location. The bartenders were great and the patrons were very nice as well
Liked the atmosphere with all the people and the live music. I tried the gouda mac and cheese then the chicken and waffles. Both were excellent.
Great selection of whiskey and bourbons.
Their ice cubes have their name stamped into it. So many options its literally crazy. Good for a casual drink or a fancy business meeting. Stay classy buffalo
The atmosphere cannot be beat...warm, historic...wood beams...great drinks! Try the beet salad, so fresh and delicious! Love it!
Amazing menu. Best selection of liquors Ive seen in Buffalo and major cities. Staff was very pleasant.
What a rip off!!!! Just found out that while I was here my credit card was skimmed and I was charged for over $100 on a day I wasnt even here. What a SHADDY place. AVOID THIS PLACE AT ALL COST!
Everytime I get food here I am blown away by how delicious it is. Also, awesome whiskey selection.
I adore this place. Love the concept and atmosphere. Best whiskey drinks in Buffalo. Service is top notch.
Super classy bar with parking right next door thats tough to beat. The live music the few times Ive been there has been consistently good and their alcohol selection is top notch.
A must stop if in area. Awesome building. Biggest selection of quality spirits I have ever seen. Good food & good service.
Very cool bar and nice cocktails. Its a big place with plenty of room to stand around if the bar is full. Though it gets very loud when its busy.
Great food. Great service. Great Wednesday night band, Rhubarb & the Alternative Dudes. Amazing whiskey. Perfect birthday night out!
Service was terrible. Slow to get a table. Slow to get drinks and slow to place an order for food. If youre willing to wait four hours for your food, then youll be okay with Lucky Day.
Happy our is Manhattans and old fashioneds which is awesome well mixed cocktails to die for hand (meat) pies cool atmosphere with 18 diameter beams.
Great drinks. I went on a Friday night at 7 and didnt have to wait too long at the bar, considering the delicious drinks take way too long to make.
Live Friday night jazz music. 9 to 12 midnight.
Visited pre covid. Loved it. The bartenders are knowledgeable and the drinks are amazing. The prices are much lower then I would have guessed.
The only bad thing about this place is the acoustics. everything else is bangin- food, drink, ambiance. the curtained downstairs tables? chefs kiss.
Very high class, fancy bar. Great cocktails and a classy atmosphere. Prices arent bad either for the upscale venue
Yummy pies and pasta in a classy atmosphere
Love this place for a fancy dinner date. Great cocktails and delicious dinners.
Great selection of whiskey, drinks are well crafted so service is sometimes understandably slow. Beer list is good too
Very nice bar with a great selection of whiskey.
Exactly what a whiskey bar so. Dark wood, great drinks and knowledgeable bartenders. Phil mixed a stunning sazerac. Every town needs a place this good.
Food was really good with nice twists on classic entrees. Drinks were on point, with possibly more whiskey options than you could drink in a lifetime.
Knowledgeable bartenders, great selection.
I mean its the best whisky bar in upstate NY. What more of a recommendation do you need.
It is a library of scotch whiskey and a place to feel fancy. The bartenders here are expert craftsmen and know their artform to the tee.
Love the setup at the bar! Youre able to be socially distant and yet still enjoy the bar feeling! Great night. Thanks!
Loved it. Food and atmosphere were fantastic. Actually learned something about whiskey
Second time coming. I had a Manhattan and a strip steak. Both were awesome.
Really enjoyed this spot. Awesome Bourbon and Whiskey list. Great craft cocktails too
What a fantastic bar with live music! The staff were super friendly. This is must whenever in the City of Buffalo.
Bartenders were very helpful in terms of suggestions of different whiskeys, being a newcomer to whiskey I had a great time experiencing different tastes
Not a whiskey drinker, but they also have a good selection of beer. Love the atmosphere
Upscale business crowd but great craft cocktails and friendly service. Would recommend for an occasional night out.
Total reviews rating 4.6
199 Reviews for Lucky Day Whiskey Bar 2023:
Review №1
2022-06-08This was a great find while visiting Buffalo. The bourbon selection is top notch! I had the daily special (halibut), but my wife ordered the bourbon chicken. Both dishes were delicious. Appetizers were very good as well.
Review №2
2022-07-01Best service. I had the dry age rib-eye steak for $70. Supposedly the steak is dried out with a rub for 20 days. It tested ok, nothing like Gordons steak. I tried the orange bourbon whip and it was good and had a kick to it. It is open until 10 so good for late night dinner and across from the Hyatt regency hotel. Quick walk.
Review №3
2022-03-05First time coming here. The food is fantastic. We had the Brussels sprouts, which were crispy and tender and full of flavor , Caesar salad and wedge salad. Highly recommend the wedge! And dinner was ribeye cooked perfectly and seafood linguine. We will definitely be back
Review №4
2022-07-07Was a very quiet Wednesday night, 6:00
Review №5
2021-12-23Whiskey selection was great and even more surprising was the excellent food. Bourbon chicken was delicious. Whiskey pickles that came with the super tender bacon app (tasted like pork candy) were a hit.
Review №6
2021-10-09This was a suggestion from our bartender at The Curtiss, and what a gem! Really cool inside, tons of bourbon and such. Seated immediately (recommend reservations on the weekend) service was excellent, food was outstanding, will definitely be back!
Review №7
2021-09-12Went for dinner. There was live music which was good. The Manhattan I had was really good. The service was good. Disappointed with the food. I ordered the strip. Steak was over cooked. Way way way too much salt on everything. Was expecting better for the prices
Review №8
2022-06-09This is a classy bar. Food was delicious (Bourbon chicken is to die for) and dont leave without having a tart glass of their strawberry lemonade. Loved the atmosphere! Fair warning... it was ridiculous loud but still loved the restaurant none the less.
Review №9
2022-04-28If youre in Buffalo, this is a must! We will plan a trip from TX to NY JUST to eat here again. If you are from Texas, you know that speaks volumes! 🤣 We both had the seafood linguine (if only seconds werean option!), cheesecake, chocolate mousse and some amazing whiskey and rye drinks. Our waiter was the bar manager, so we had choice options for some tasty drinks! Thank you for a splendid last night in Buffalo!
Review №10
2022-01-05Food was flavorless. The Sprite had plenty of flavor though. Went with a party of 4 and we all agreed. The food has a high price point, which makes eating here a troubling experience. The drinks were good. Service was great. Decor is very nice, nice use of space. I saw another review that their steak was over salted. I find that hard to believe as there was no indication of seasoning visually or on the tongue. This tells me whoever is cooking makes a huge difference. The dishes were all handsome works of art. The execution of technique was perfect. They just really dropped the ball on flavor. I can tell it was an artist back there; but for whatever reason - whether it be damaged taste buds, feud with an owner, or volatile policy on how to serve their customers, they didnt produce a good dish out of the 8 that we ordered. With the high price point, we certainly will not be back.